I always find this opinion genuinely surprising. I’m a rubbish pinball player - I struggle to get to Destroy the Ring on LoTR - and I absolutely LOVE JP2 and GZ. They have a huge ‘one more game’ quality because I *want* to do better. I *want* to shoot better, I *want* to aim better, I *want* to get the combos going.
When I play ‘easier’ and ‘more accessible’ pins, the gameplay feels really dull and unsatisfying because it feels like playing one of those old-style carnival machines, or pressing the buttons on the mechanical attractions in museums/zoos - I’m just flapping the ball around to see what happens.
If you end up with a JP at home, you may feel differently. I've had JPLE since release and I loved it at first. Loved it. Over time though, I found it more and more frustrating. The paddock gameplay loop for me is fun until it's time to hit the two targets behind the jeep, then the right ramp for the helicopter, and then the roaming dinosaur, but back to the right ramp if you don't hit the dinosaur in time. The targets behind the jeep can be difficult yet still somewhat fun, but if you don't have that helicopter shot dialled in then it's just an exercise in sheer frustration.
And this is coming from someone who tends to like having hard games at home - loved Iron Man enough to have had both the original and vault edition, really enjoying my Rick and Morty, loved TNA etc.
The only reason I still own JPLE is I have a long term deal in the works with a mate who really wants it. If not for that it would have gone a year ago.
When I say I like the gameplay of JP2, I also love TNA, which the pinball equivalent of trying to ride rodeo when you’ve never seen a horse - it’s three balls of getting chucked onto the pavement and hoping next time you can hang on for a second longer. The TNA playfield alone is the old joke about Australia - even the scoop is trying to kill you. My Flipper Beast (five year old) didn’t enjoy the TNA at Flip Out - he had three ball saves instead of a game.
I like Led Zep enough that, if one turned up in my front room tomorrow morning, I wouldn’t be disappointed. If a Mando turned up, on the other hand, I’d only be interested in the resale value.
I was the original owner of the TNA that's now at Flip Out. Nowhere near as frustrating as JP in my opinion, not by a long shot. My non pinhead friends used to always be up for a game of that, none of them like JP after getting some time in on it.
The visuals on JP2 are terrible. The playfield artwork is dull and grungy - it’s on par with LoTR. There’s no visual coherence between the JP film clips, weird mannequin CGI pseudo video artwork, and terrible (DNA) cartoons. The T-Rex, although spectacularly cool in theory, looks like he’s briefly dropped in on the way to another pin. He’s also criminally underused in the gameplay…
The custom code with the movie assets is fantastic and almost enough to get me to keep the game. Not quite though.