What's new
Pinball info

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

HLD (again)

Is there some level of resentment towards HLD that after paying the going rate for a game that they somehow manage to extract thousands from some unsuspecting noob with more cash than sense? Or is it just sour grapes that we can't seem to make sales with that amount of mark-up? To me it's just the difference between a private seller and a business. Exactly the same thing happens with cars. Garages get second-hand cars for a fair price from private sellers or as a part exchange, then change the oil, valet the inside and slap on a bit of Turtle Wax then added £££ to price before placing on the forecourt. Part of what you're paying for is peace-of-mind as even second-hand car sales are covered by consumer regulation and sales are made with a warranty. It's like when I bought my Zafira from Vauxhall. I probably paid about a grand more than a private sale, but I sure got my money's worth out the three-year extended warranty they included! Do HLD offer any kind of warranty/support?
 
They're VAT registered too so that's an extra 20% factored into their prices for 2nd hand machines
 
Is there some level of resentment towards HLD that after paying the going rate for a game that they somehow manage to extract thousands from some unsuspecting noob with more cash than sense? Or is it just sour grapes that we can't seem to make sales with that amount of mark-up? To me it's just the difference between a private seller and a business. Exactly the same thing happens with cars. Garages get second-hand cars for a fair price from private sellers or as a part exchange, then change the oil, valet the inside and slap on a bit of Turtle Wax then added £££ to price before placing on the forecourt. Part of what you're paying for is peace-of-mind as even second-hand car sales are covered by consumer regulation and sales are made with a warranty. It's like when I bought my Zafira from Vauxhall. I probably paid about a grand more than a private sale, but I sure got my money's worth out the three-year extended warranty they included! Do HLD offer any kind of warranty/support?
I was about to reply with this exact stuff in response to your first post in the thread - you are absolutely right. There are also people that feel like they were taken advantage of because their ultimate aim was to offer a cheap game to get more people in their hobby, coming to shows and meets and posting on the board etc. For those people, I very much agree with them. But for everyone else that doesn't have that goal in mind and just wants a sale, then gets mad when it turns up on HLD, what you say does apply.

We say more money than sense in cases of sales like this - and personally I still believe that to be utterly true - but it has always been the way, time immaterial, that people with a lot of free cash will sometimes pay over the odds to us, in order to just not worry about any of the technicalities.

A £2K mark-up on a pinball would be unjustified for any amount of work to me. But I can say that because I am happy to work on repairs myself and I don't need a warranty or an installation - and I don't consider the process of learning how to do the work (or the years of already learnt skills involving restoration work on complex devices like cars, and electronic repair at circuit diagnostic level) as part of that cost. I enjoyed learning that stuff and I find it invaluable going forward.

The fly in the ointment, where all of this falls over for me, are the statements that I have read from people that have sold to HLD, selling pins with known issues that needed work, and then seeing them relisted on the site very quickly, with that same heavy markup, with photos that strongly suggest that the work wasn't done prior to sale and photography. That does lend legitimate ammunition of lazy profiteering by sales achieved with the aid of a sheen of professionalism.

But I wonder, in that case, how they can make significant profit selling machines with issues if they offer a servicing warranty... surely that profit evaporates if they have to keep tending to a machine with issues? So even those rumors must be taken with salt.

Overall I think people in hobbies, in general and not just here, are too quick to undersell the value of their skills and time - heck, your enthusiasm is a value alone.
 
I will however say though I am too much of a mug to accept an obviously ridiculous offer (+£2k) from a new person if I was the seller of a pin on this forum.

Yes that money would be welcome, but I prefer honest deals. My morality streak is too wide for me not to feel guilty about taking advantage of someone like that. The guy I bought my F14 from actually said that he felt bad for me when I handed over the money, and then started to point out all of the problems and required repairs while taking it apart for transport - I was just amused. I'm that kind of guy.
Of course if it was an utter mong of a person with demonstrably more money than sense it would salve my concerns a little bit. But I can't say that I would be happy selling to that person in the first place. Not something that isn't being made anymore...
 
But I wonder, in that case, how they can make significant profit selling machines with issues if they offer a servicing warranty... surely that profit evaporates if they have to keep tending to a machine with issues? So even those rumors must be taken with salt.

Their warranty as I understand it is for parts only. So they literally post you a spare part and then you either learn to solder or pay someone else to fit it.
 
We really need to know who's accounts on here are from traders or not. Trader list or symbol near their names perhaps?. More transparency in who you are actually dealing with will allow people to make a more informed decision on who they want to deal with.
 
Their warranty as I understand it is for parts only. So they literally post you a spare part and then you either learn to solder or pay someone else to fit it.
If true then the complaints against and singling-out of HLD in particular, will indeed have merit.

Though their warranty policy (esp section 7.4) seems to be standard, it is a red flag to me that nowhere else on their website offers any reassurance that they will repair any issues encountered.
 
We really need to know who's accounts on here are from traders or not. Trader list or symbol near their names perhaps?. More transparency in who you are actually dealing with will allow people to make a more informed decision on who they want to deal with.
Doesn't work. Dealers in arcade (and from what I see, pinball as well) forums will also go in with sockpuppet accounts because they know full well that many people don't wish to deal with them. The only way to prevent sales to dealers is unworkable; that is to shut off all sales to new people. A good way to doom a hobby.
 
I fully agree with Nedreud, but on the basis that people who are buying for HLD (or other businesses) are clear and up front that they are doing so.

Coming onto this forum as 'Joe Public' and buying up machines without it being clear who they are isn't really on in my view, particularly if people on here are trying to sell their machines in a bid to attract new people to the hobby. Just my opinion of course.

But PBrookfield is of course right; you can't enforce that and you rely on people to be honest and open.
 
What amuses me is how they can list a RRP price against machines that are not new in box, especially ones shown in their 'Vintage' section. Of course, all their prices show a reduction in their actual retail price against the RRP price to give the perception that you are getting a great deal. Did you know the RRP for a TaF is £7997 so their list price of £7497 is a steal! :rofl:
 
I suspect the price would be more than £7997 if they took the original price and applied inflation.

But you really can't compare that way; if you go to a second hand car dealership they don't try flogging you the car based on what it would cost new because it's clear NOT new. Similarly a restored Pin will never be worth as much as a NIB.

But then i'd say it's probably fair to say that the majority of people buying from HLD probably aren't fans of Pinball and thus don't know what the going rate would be anyway.
 
a lot of folks are having a go at HLD and some of the nutters on eBay but this forum is not as safe to buy as stated by a few here. Whatever you are buying be careful.

Neil.
 
If true then the complaints against and singling-out of HLD in particular, will indeed have merit.

Though their warranty policy (esp section 7.4) seems to be standard, it is a red flag to me that nowhere else on their website offers any reassurance that they will repair any issues encountered.

Not sure where you're seeing a warranty with section numbers, maybe for other products? They have this on the Classic Pinball pages:

"This pinball machine comes with a 1 year parts warranty. All parts that are faulty will be replaced. Often we can solve any problems over the phone and supply any necessary components for the customer to fit. If necessary our specialist repairer can visit your home to inspect and repair your machine on-site, but this would be chargeable. Please call us for a call-out quotation. If parts are required which are not carried at the time these will need to be ordered for you, and will sometimes need to be imported from the States - therefore, there can be a wait for the part to arrive.

After our 1 year warranty has expired we will continue to offer you complete support for any problems you have, either over the phone or by email, and can provide a chargeable engineer call out should it be required. Whatever happens, we will be able to look after you and your pinball machine.

Pinball machines are complicated items, which don't like being moved about, nor do they like the cold or humidity. Therefore, if you chose to move the pinball machine from where we originally installed it, or it is stored in a cold or damp location, our warranty will become null and void. We won't be able to supply any parts for your machine free of charge if it has been accidentally damaged or you have tampered with it in any way.

Commercial Use:

We don't offer any warranty for used pinball machines used in a commercial environment, however we can provide an engineer to perform any repairs necessary on a chargeable basis."
 
Whatever you are buying be careful.
Couldn't agree more. The only time I would lower my ASG (Automatic Suspicion Guard) would be dealing with people on here I'd met in person or were known friends/
acquaintances of people I've met and those with an already good reputation within the pinball community. It would also depend on the value of the item. If someone I didn't know was offering some ancient Bally doo-hicky for £5 that I needed I'd take a punt because (a) it's unlikely to be a scam due to obscure nature and (b) I'd pay via PayPal so zero exposure and only the risk of losing a few quid. If it was a whole machine for thousands, that would require a visit and full inspection, and then finally a bank transfer. I would never take that amount of cash to a collection. And I probably wouldn't go alone. But these are general rules for buying and selling on the internet.
 
about sums up the "joy" of pinball in one statement..

Pinball machines are complicated items, which don't like being moved about
 
Not sure where you're seeing a warranty with section numbers, maybe for other products?
The part you've found on the pinballs page, they will probably point to as an 'override' for the standard T&C, which is a shame.
But specifically I found their 'plain' terms and conditions by following, from the home page, 'About Us' at the top, then near the bottom to 'Terms & Conditions' which includes a section 7, with part 7.4 of the most note:

7.1 We warrant that subject to these Conditions upon delivery and for a period of 12 months from the date of delivery the Goods will be:
7.1.1of satisfactory quality within the meaning of the Sale of Goods Act 1979;
7.1.2 reasonably fit for the purpose for which the Goods are being sold by Us;
7.1.3 reasonably fit for the purpose for which the Goods are being bought if You had made known that purpose to Us in writing and We have confirmed acceptance of the purpose in writing.

7.2 Subject to clauses 5.10 and 5.11, We shall not be liable for a breach of any of the warranties in clause 7.1 unless:
7.2.1 You give written notice of the defect to Us within 7 days of when You discover or ought to have discovered the defect; and
7.2.2 We are given a reasonable opportunity after receiving the notice of examining the Goods and You (if asked to do so) return the Goods to Our place of business at Our cost.

7.3 We shall not be liable for a breach of the warranties in clause 7.1 where;
7.3.1 You make any further use of the Goods after giving such notice as required by clause 7.2.1
7.3.2 the defect arises because You failed to follow Our oral or written instructions as to the storage, installation, use of, or maintenance of the Goods; or
7.3.3 You alter or repair the Goods without Our written consent

7.4 Subject to the provisions of this clause 7, if any of the Goods do not conform with any of the warranties in clause 7.1, You may request that We repair or replace the Goods or refund the full price of such Goods provided that on Our request You shall (at Our cost and expense) return the Goods or the part of the Goods which is defective to Us.

https://www.homeleisuredirect.com/company/terms.aspx
 
Surely 2 simple points here ....
  1. Warn forum users (automated warning when posting games for sale ?) that commercial traders may be using fake IDs, may be pretending that they are enthusiasts and are seeking to buy games covertly on the forum. This breaches the spirit of our community. Honest traders are welcome, deceitful ones are not.
  2. If this bothers you, then investigate the bona fides of potential buyers for your game. If it does not bother you, please do as you wish
 
Just sold a machine to HLD.

They didn’t pretend to be someone else, were open for the start as to who they were so that’s fine with me

It’s a shame as I guess it means it is now out of circulation amongst forum members but had been for sale for two weeks so everyone had ample chance. If none of us want it then let HLD sell it to a footballer at a profit , I don’t care. It’s a hobby to us but a business to them and there’s lots of things that are like that .

They were excellent to deal with , collected it no haggling straight forward

Not sure what I’ll do if they jump in quick on a machine I’m selling as I’d rather they stayed in the group but otherwise I would be happy to sell to them again if no one else wants . Certainly rather do that than ebay
 
I suspect the fact they were excellent to deal with is largely down to the big fat profit they'll be getting excited about when they flog the machine on. ;-)

Each to their own. People can sell to who they want; but it'd be good to keep this in mind when people complain about the lack of second-hand pins being put up for sale on the forum. Sooner or later the machines which seem to go round and round the forum members will all end up in the hands of people like HLD and then we'll have little choice but to either pay their price or look elsewhere at other places where the prices are also likely to be higher.

Pinflation has been bad enough lately. I suspect it's only going to get worse.
 
It was a very good price and didn't get snapped up on here. I would do the same rather than making a bigger loss.
 
You did the right thing Andy you gave people on here the opportunity to buy it and no body did put up or shut up in my book
I have also sold to hld but they didn’t tell me it was them but they didn’t knock me on price turned up and took away paid there and then
I find it a bit sad that pins don’t get snapped up on here particularly my top end stuff sadly a fair bit of that goes over sees
 
I would guess a typical HLD buyer would be expecting to take a loss when they want to move it on as no one would pay them what they paid for it, which would probably bring it back into circulation. They probably treat it like a car or other such items which are expected to drop in value. Fair play if no one wants to buy it on here.
 
Sounds like they've upped their game a bit though. I read a post some time ago that they asked for a VAT form, which is a bit of a bonkers expectation from a small private seller.

The games are worth what they're worth at the end of the day. Either they sell from HLD's prices or they won't. And if they sell, eventually the owners will move it on, and either get similar money or take a loss. That's just how it is.

Reading the kinds of prices that used to be paid for games, the all-time-low for prices was insane and is bonkers to expect to see again. Games trading for shockingly close to the copper scrap value in the wiring in the looms!
 
I just sold my G&R to HLD. First time I have dealt with them but it was a hassle free transaction. I advertised it here at £3500 for a month or so with no takers and had moved it to ebay so it was fair game as far as I was concerned. They also paid £250 more than I was asking here so i don't think it was over priced. I was very surprised it didn't go here but you can't expect to sell within the forum every time.
 
Interesting times for sure.

New games are now sooooo expensive that they have made older games 'seem' cheap. So, HLD can snap up all the old games as their buyers just see them as being cheaper than NIB. £9500 for a Stern LE where the only difference between say a 2003 LOTR is a LCD screen! ( and LOTR was better quality.... )

I don't know about others but I think 2018 will be my quietest year for swopping games around since 2009.
 
Haven't dealt with HLD but don't have a problem with what they are doing. It's a business after all. We've all got bills to pay, we all just do it in different ways.
 
Back
Top Bottom