Stop itMaiden . . . . it's ranked the 5th greatest pinball machine of all time
Pinball info
Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
OK, Most Overrated Pinball Machine
- Thread starter Tucks
- Start date
I'm going to say Stern JP, no.2 on the Pinside chart? I'd like to own one to change my mind...
The next stern after jaws
The Shadow and Batman 66.
Not going to be popular….but DP! I’d have Rush over this all day
There are a lot of them… same as TAF (which is overvalued, but not actually overrated).
Very rarely do you see Addams family come up
As the biggest rush fan around.....
I just absolutely hated the artwork on Rush.
But after they ruined Led Zeppelin with an awful looking machine - what more do you expect from Stern.
I'd have to say Deadpool. It's fun but ultimately a bit dull after a short time.
How very dare you
Sorry lads but the fact so many people rate it means to me it's overrated. I liked it enough but so many better games
I have seen sone truly despicable things posted on line but too call Deadpool overrated blasphemy, you sir deserve to be put in the corner with Neil
Neil's contribution to Pinballinfo was UNDERRATED imo
I think the 'Most Overrated' and 'Most Underrated' threads could have their titles swapped around and no one would know the difference.
For me, the idea of something being underrated is one where folks might be considered to revisit something that isn't popular but was actually good.
This thread is about highlighting how you don't like something other people think is good.
This thread is about highlighting how you don't like something other people think is good.
STTNG (bet no one saw that coming)
New to the forum and a proud sttng owner, I have to ask why? I have owned mine for over 10 years and love it.
Planning on selling it soon as I am moving to the States, but I am intrigued as to why you don't rate it positively?
Thanks
Dave
Don't listen to him, he's just wrong.
Bally "Playboy"
Looks great, but if you can max out the bonus on the first ball (and that is not hard), everything else is a waste of time
Looks great, but if you can max out the bonus on the first ball (and that is not hard), everything else is a waste of time
There is nothing wrong with any of the games nominated, it is just for some reason people do not feel they deserve an "A+" rating
If we are going off rankings and If JP2 is the 2nd highest rated pin on pinside, then that would have to get my vote. not saying I don't like it but not even close to being the 2nd best game I've ever played.
This doesn’t class as overrated- but the context was I’d commented on a Stern advertisement for their Supreme pin on YouTube- even they know it’s a pile of s***
