I've been watching a fair amount of Pinball Shenanigans and always found it odd how he seems to be playing in 3ish tournaments at the same time. Still very new on the scene but have been enjoying the uk tournaments ive been to so far. It feels to me like the size of the venues in America with their larger quantities of pins could be what facilitates that approach.
I also don't think id want divisions in tournaments for different quality players, playing in a tournament with some of the best players in the country like Greg, Josh, Pete etc can be very daunting and demotivating initially knowing you're not going to win but personally I've found everyone including them to be very welcoming and offering advice on what to aim for. Plus watching them play has taught me so much which I wouldn't get with divisions. oh and if I do even come close to taking a game from them I ride that high for a week
I sympathised with the beginning of his video because there have been a couple of tournaments where we've had to leave before the end because our childcare 'ran out', or where I've had to disappear midway through to get lunch or simply some fresh air!
However, I didn't fully understand why he felt matchplay made a tournament scene less competitive. It felt like (to be uncharitable) his model of a tournament is to keep submitting scores to grind your 1,320,322 to 1,320,350, and that reducing this numerical complexity to 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th place lost something somehow.
Personally, I enjoy matchplay. Not only because, as he says, it's beginner friendly because better players give tips and there can be upsets but, also, because you're focused on beating other players rather than score maximisation/grinding. If everyone in your four-player game is struggling on a really tough Fish Tales, for example, you can go for video mode for the win!! If it's a 'best-card' tournament, the temptation is to grind monster fish/caster's club because those are the only high-scoring options for that machine.
To be honest, I think people naturally create their own divisions. I think everyone playing regularly (in the UK) knows who plays similar standard to them (and, if they don't, IPFA has stats) and you can benchmark yourself against how those players are doing - you don't need to be pre-sorted into groups
