I'll give it a go, as I will anything, I didn't like TAF at all, it's gone up in my estimations, but IMHO it isn't worth what it fetches, same for
AFM - I enjoy that but would MUCH rather a MM.
It is of course horses for courses, but a Top WHATEVER does bench out more enjoyable games than others, so there is something to be said for that. That is why there is generally this concept in my mind of
Bad:
Dialed In, Twilight Zone, Roadshow
Good:
World Poker Tour, Judge Dredd,
Better:
Scared Stiff, Ghostbusters, Attack From Mars, AC/DC
Best:
Iron Maiden, The Walking Dead, Medievel Madness, Monster Bash
So I disagree, I think there are BAD games, ones that I am playing and thinking, man I just don't like this game